Fr. Treco in the dock, Bishop Lopes declares his verdict . . .

And announces condign sentence.

Fr. Treco, in the dock for heresy and/or schism, objected to Bishop Lopes’ false, misleading or accusatory” comments about his homily and said nothing he had said called for excommunication.

Bishop L. said Fr. T. had retracted none of his “erroneous positions” and had spoken rather of hiscandor” and willingness to undergo “instruction and correction,” failing “to address the heart of the problem.”

He has accepted only those doctrines and practices approved prior to the 1960s, the bishop said.

Not exactly.

Fr. T. had said,

We can choose to teach the true Faith, and only the true Faith to our children! In this regard, a helpful rule of thumb would be to return to those theological and spiritual resources that were approved by the Holy See prior to the revolution of the 1960s!”

In any case, the preacher had argued for his position at length in a long sermon full of sweeping statements — but also offering historical details which the bishop ignores, such as actions taken and comments made by Vatican 2 popes.

Bishop L. accused him of failing to accept Vatican 2 “as an expression of the authentic and universal magisterium of the Church.”

He’s correct. Fr. T. had mounted a frontal attack on Vatican 2, even recommending to his people, “We can Resist!”

Furthermore, he had implicated every Vatican 2 pope:

[Y]ou believe that the current crisis in the Church has been caused by Pope St. John XXIII, Pope St. Paul VI, Pope John Paul I, Pope St. John Paul II, Pope Benedict XVI, and Pope Francis who, in your words [5] all have denied Christ and [6] set aside the mandate given by Christ to St. Peter. . .

Oh my. Where can a bishop go with this stuff? It may not incite the faithful, but it incites bishops. Fr. Treco can use an editor.

Bishop L. said his “personal statement” about Vatican 2 “does not sufficiently reaffirm” his Profession of Faith taken in 2014 prior to being ordained a Catholic priest the next year and “intentionally calls into doubt the supreme magisterium of the Second Vatican Council….”

Score one for the bishop, who himself seems to be laying it on a bit thick. It was famously a “pastoral council” in which nothing was “defined,” as councils ordinarily do. So arguing with it seems not a capital offense. Tell that to the bishop.

The coup de grace:

Given these deficiencies, and having concluded that you are not recanting [reversing] positions that you take in your homily that [spread] confusion and [incite] animosity to the Apostolic See among the faithful, the question remains, Father Treco, do you stand by your homily or are you prepared to retract it and renew and sign the Church’s Profession of Faith.” 


I require you [not only] to retract the homily, [but also to ask] the websites where it is published to remove the text. A statement of retraction is to be published in your [parish] bulletin, as well as [on] your personal website, Facebook pages, and any other social media platforms you administer.

Erase it all, he says, and while you’re at it, remove yourself as a preacher and guide for souls.

So that further scandal can be avoided, your reaffirmation of the Profession of Faith is to be made known to your parish community.

To which he will return, their leader no more.


A copy of this retraction is to be sent to the Chancery for your personal file.


As your public dissent has caused harm to our Ordinariate and calls into question the ecclesial fidelity and ministry of every Ordinariate priest, you are to author a brief note of apology to your brother priests of the Ordinariate of the Chair of Saint Peter. This you will send to me for publication to our presbyterate. 

Lest any think such a path as you have taken be an option for any but the very foolish.

More to come on this matter, but there’s a major aspect of the bishop’s overall response, that Fr. T. is in the way of poisoning the well of a very new, you might say experimental, operation, a welcoming to dissident Anglicans who have had it with Anglican shilly-shallying in re faith and morals, arriving in the bosom of Holy Mother Church, priests with wives and children. 

More later on the organization and its North American leader, appointed by Francis after a short but semi-meteoric Vatican career.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s